# Lampiran A — Kumpulan Template Praktis > Template-template dari setiap bab dikumpulkan di sini untuk referensi cepat. > Setiap template merujuk ke bab asalnya untuk konteks dan penjelasan lengkap. --- ## Daftar Template | # | Nama Template | Dari Bab | Bagian | |---|---------------|----------|--------| | A.1 | Research Mindset Self-Assessment | Bab 1 | I | | A.2 | Problem Statement Builder | Bab 2 | I | | A.3 | Literature Mapping & Gap Identification | Bab 3 | I | | A.4 | RQ-Contribution-Hypothesis | Bab 4 | I | | A.5 | Definisi Variabel, Metrik & Justifikasi | Bab 5 | II | | A.6 | Mapping RQ ke Arsitektur Sistem | Bab 6 | II | | A.7 | Desain Eksperimen Lengkap | Bab 7 | II | | A.8 | Integration Checklist (Proposal Checkpoint) | Bab 8 | III | | A.9 | Dokumentasi Setup Eksperimen | Bab 9 | III | | A.10 | Execution Plan & Data Log | Bab 10 | III | | A.11 | Data Validation Checklist | Bab 11 | III | | A.12 | Result Presentation Plan | Bab 12 | IV | | A.13 | Preprocessing Documentation Log | Bab 13 | IV | | A.14 | Analysis & Interpretation Report | Bab 14 | IV | | A.15 | Paper Structure Checklist | Bab 15 | IV | | A.16 | Defense Preparation Sheet | Bab 16 | IV | --- > **Catatan penggunaan:** > Setiap template dirancang untuk diisi secara progresif seiring kemajuan riset. Template dari Bagian I (Bab 1–4) menghasilkan fondasi yang digunakan oleh template Bagian II (Bab 5–7), dan seterusnya. Untuk konteks lengkap, penjelasan setiap field, dan contoh pengisian, rujuk ke section "Template Praktis" di bab masing-masing. --- ## A.1 — Research Mindset Self-Assessment (Bab 1) ``` Nama Peneliti : ____________________ Tanggal : ____________________ 1. Ketika membaca klaim "metode X 95% akurat": - Pertanyaan pertama saya: ____________________ - Data apa yang saya butuhkan untuk memverifikasi: ____________________ 2. Posisi paradigma: - Pendekatan saya: [ ] Positivis [ ] Interpretivis [ ] Design Science [ ] Mixed - Alasan: ____________________ 3. Identifikasi distorsi: - Asumsi tersembunyi dalam riset saya: ____________________ - Sumber bias potensial: ____________________ - Langkah mitigasi: ____________________ 4. Komitmen etika: - Data yang saya tidak akan manipulasi: ____________________ - Batasan yang saya akui sejak awal: ____________________ ``` --- ## A.2 — Problem Statement Builder (Bab 2) ``` PROBLEM STATEMENT BUILDER Domain & Konteks Domain : ____________________ Konteks : ____________________ System Context Input : ____________________ Process : ____________________ Output : ____________________ Outcome : ____________________ Constraints : ____________________ Stakeholders: ____________________ Fenomena → Problem Fenomena yang diamati : ____________________ Gejala (symptom) yang terukur : ____________________ Masalah yang didiagnosis : ____________________ Masalah riset (researchable) : ____________________ Variabel yang terukur : ____________________ Problem Quality Check [ ] Clarity — Apakah satu orang membaca akan paham? [ ] Measurability — Apakah ada metrik kuantitatif? [ ] Relevance — Apakah penting untuk domain? [ ] Testability — Apakah bisa gagal? [ ] Impact — Apakah ada kontribusi jika terjawab? Problem Statement (1 paragraf): ____________________ ``` --- ## A.3 — Literature Mapping & Gap Identification (Bab 3) ``` LITERATURE MAPPING Topik : ____________________ Database : ____________________ Query : ____________________ Tahun : ____________________ Hasil awal : ____ paper → Screening → ____ paper final Literature Matrix (concept-centric): | Study | Tahun | Method | Data | Result | Limitation | |-------|-------|--------|------|--------|------------| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Pola yang ditemukan: Metode dominan : ____________________ Dataset umum : ____________________ Limitasi berulang : ____________________ GAP IDENTIFICATION Gap 1: [Jenis: performance / method / data / context] Deskripsi : ____________________ Bukti : ____________________ Signifikansi: ____________________ Gap 2: [Jenis: ____] Deskripsi : ____________________ Bukti : ____________________ Signifikansi: ____________________ Baseline Selection: | Baseline | Relevansi | Representatif | Source | |----------|-----------|---------------|--------| | | | | | | | | | | ``` --- ## A.4 — RQ-Contribution-Hypothesis (Bab 4) ``` RQ-CONTRIBUTION-HYPOTHESIS Gap Statement : ____________________ Research Question: Tipe : [ ] Comparison [ ] Improvement [ ] Exploratory Formulasi : ____________________ Variabel IV : ____________________ Variabel DV : ____________________ Metrik : ____________________ Dataset : ____________________ Baseline : ____________________ Quality Check RQ: [ ] Variabel spesifik [ ] Metrik jelas [ ] Baseline ada [ ] Konteks disebutkan [ ] Memerlukan eksperimen (bukan hanya survei literatur) Contribution Statement: Apa yang baru diketahui : ____________________ Jenis kontribusi : [ ] Improvement [ ] Comparison [ ] Novel approach Gap yang diisi : ____________________ Hypothesis Pair: H₀ : ____________________ H₁ : ____________________ Threshold : ____________________ Justifikasi threshold : ____________________ ``` --- ## A.5 — Definisi Variabel, Metrik & Justifikasi (Bab 5) ``` VARIABLE & METRIC DEFINITION Research Question: ____________________ | Variabel | Tipe | Konsep | Metrik | Skala | Satuan | Cara Mengukur | Justifikasi | |----------|------|--------|--------|-------|--------|---------------|-------------| | | IV | | | | | | | | | DV | | | | | | | | | CV | | | | | | | Alignment Check: RQ → Concept → Variable → Metric → Data → Result [ ] Setiap langkah terdokumentasi [ ] Tidak ada "lompatan logis" [ ] Metrik mengukur apa yang dimaksud (construct validity) ``` --- ## A.6 — Mapping RQ ke Arsitektur Sistem (Bab 6) ``` SYSTEM-EXPERIMENT MAPPING Research Question: ____________________ Variable → Component Mapping: | Variabel | Tipe | Komponen Sistem | Cara Manipulasi/Pengukuran | |----------|------|-----------------|---------------------------| | | IV | | | | | DV | | | | | CV | | | 4 Prinsip Desain: [ ] Traceability — Setiap komponen bisa ditelusuri ke variabel [ ] Variable Isolation — IV bisa diubah tanpa mengubah CV [ ] Measurement Integration — Pengukuran DV built-in [ ] Reproducibility — Setup bisa direkonstruksi Experimental Setup: Input data : ____________________ Parameter : ____________________ Output format : ____________________ ``` --- ## A.7 — Desain Eksperimen Lengkap (Bab 7) ``` EXPERIMENT DESIGN Research Question : ____________________ Hypothesis : ____________________ Tipe Eksperimen : [ ] Comparison [ ] Ablation [ ] Parameter Kondisi Eksperimen: | Kondisi | Deskripsi | IV Value | CV Settings | |---------|-----------|----------|-------------| | Control | | | | | Treatment | | | | Fairness Checklist: [ ] Dataset identik untuk semua kondisi [ ] Preprocessing setara [ ] Tuning effort setara [ ] Environment identik [ ] Metrik evaluasi sama Threat Analysis: | Threat Type | Ancaman Spesifik | Mitigasi | |-------------|-----------------|----------| | Internal | | | | External | | | | Construct | | | | Conclusion | | | Statistical Plan: Uji statistik : ____________________ Justifikasi : ____________________ Alpha : ____________________ Effect size min : ____________________ ``` --- ## A.8 — Integration Checklist / Proposal Checkpoint (Bab 8) ``` PROPOSAL INTEGRATION CHECKLIST Koneksi Vertikal (Flow Atas-Bawah): [ ] Problem → Gap: masalah terdokumentasi di literatur [ ] Gap → RQ: pertanyaan menjawab gap spesifik [ ] RQ → Hypothesis: hipotesis memprediksi jawaban [ ] Hypothesis → Metric: metrik mengukur variabel dalam hipotesis [ ] Metric → System: komponen sistem menghasilkan/mengukur metrik [ ] System → Experiment: desain eksperimen menggunakan sistem Koneksi Horizontal (Konsistensi): [ ] Istilah sama di semua bagian [ ] Variabel yang disebut di RQ = variabel di hipotesis = metrik di desain [ ] Scope tidak berubah dari masalah ke eksperimen Rubrik Self-Assessment: | Kriteria | 1 (Lemah) | 2 (Cukup) | 3 (Baik) | Skor | |----------|-----------|-----------|----------|------| | Koherensi | | | | | | Specificity | | | | | | Feasibility | | | | | | Rigor | | | | | ``` --- ## A.9 — Dokumentasi Setup Eksperimen (Bab 9) ``` EXPERIMENT SETUP DOCUMENTATION Hardware: CPU : ____________________ RAM : ____________________ GPU : ____________________ Storage: ____________________ Software: OS : ____________________ Runtime : ____________________ Framework: ____________________ Dependencies: | Library | Version | Sumber | Hash/Checksum | |---------|---------|--------|---------------| | | | | | Konfigurasi: Config file : ____________________ Seed : ____________________ Hyperparameters: ____________________ Reproducibility Check: [ ] Dependency terdokumentasi (requirements.txt / lock file) [ ] Seed ditetapkan [ ] Config di version control [ ] README instruksi reproduksi ``` --- ## A.10 — Execution Plan & Data Log (Bab 10) ``` EXECUTION PLAN | Run # | Skenario | Seed | Parameter | Status | Waktu | Output File | |-------|----------|------|-----------|--------|-------|-------------| | 1 | | | | | | | | 2 | | | | | | | | ... | | | | | | | Jumlah runs per skenario : ____ Total runs : ____ DATA LOG (per run): Run ID : ____________________ Timestamp : ____________________ Skenario : ____________________ Input : ____________________ Output : ____________________ Anomali : ____________________ Catatan : ____________________ ``` --- ## A.11 — Data Validation Checklist (Bab 11) ``` DATA VALIDATION CHECKLIST Completeness: [ ] Semua skenario tercakup [ ] Jumlah run sesuai rencana [ ] Tidak ada file output yang hilang Missing: ____ dari ____ data points Format Consistency: [ ] Semua file format sama (CSV/JSON/...) [ ] Header konsisten [ ] Tipe data konsisten (numerik tetap numerik) Range & Logic: [ ] Nilai dalam range yang masuk akal [ ] Tidak ada waktu negatif [ ] Akurasi 0–100%, bukan di luar range Anomali ditemukan: ____________________ Cross-Validation: [ ] Run identik → hasil mendekati (tidak beda ordo magnitudo) [ ] Trend konsisten dengan ekspektasi teori (jika ada) Keputusan: [ ] Data siap analisis [ ] Perlu cleaning (lihat Bab 13) [ ] Perlu re-run (skenario: ____) ``` --- ## A.12 — Result Presentation Plan (Bab 12) ``` RESULT PRESENTATION PLAN Research Question: ____________________ Metrik Utama : ____________________ Tabel Hasil: | Skenario | Metrik 1 (mean ± std) | Metrik 2 (mean ± std) | n | |----------|----------------------|----------------------|---| | | | | | Visualisasi yang Direncanakan: | # | Jenis Grafik | Pesan Utama | Metrik | |---|-------------|-------------|--------| | 1 | | | | | 2 | | | | Bias Check: [ ] Y-axis mulai dari 0 (atau dijustifikasi) [ ] Error bar/CI ditampilkan [ ] Semua data disertakan (tidak cherry-picked) [ ] Tidak menggunakan 3D tanpa alasan ``` --- ## A.13 — Preprocessing Documentation Log (Bab 13) ``` PREPROCESSING LOG Dataset : ____________________ Jumlah data awal : ____________________ Cleaning: | Masalah | Jumlah Kasus | Penanganan | Justifikasi | |---------|-------------|------------|-------------| | Missing | | | | | Duplikat| | | | | Error | | | | Transformation: | Transformasi | Variabel | Detail | Alasan | |-------------|----------|--------|--------| | | | | | Normalization: Metode : ____________________ Alasan : ____________________ Parameter : (dihitung dari: training set / seluruh data) Leakage Check: [ ] Parameter normalisasi dari training set saja [ ] Tidak ada informasi test set dalam preprocessing [ ] Cross-validation dilakukan setelah split Jumlah data akhir: ____________________ Script tersedia : [ ] Ya → path: ____ | [ ] Belum ``` --- ## A.14 — Analysis & Interpretation Report (Bab 14) ``` ANALYSIS & INTERPRETATION 1. Statistik Deskriptif: | Skenario | Mean | Std | Median | Min | Max | n | |----------|------|-----|--------|-----|-----|---| | | | | | | | | 2. Uji Hipotesis: Uji yang digunakan : ____________________ Justifikasi : ____________________ Hasil: p = ____, effect size (d/r/η²) = ____ CI 95% : [____, ____] 3. Keputusan: [ ] H₀ ditolak → H₁ diterima [ ] H₀ tidak ditolak 4. Interpretasi: Hubungan ke RQ : ____________________ Practical significance: ____________________ Perbandingan literatur: ____________________ 5. Limitation: | Jenis | Ancaman | Dampak | Mitigasi | |-------|---------|--------|----------| | | | | | 6. Failure Analysis (jika H₀ tidak ditolak): Penyebab potensial: ____________________ Boundary condition : ____________________ Insight : ____________________ ``` --- ## A.15 — Paper Structure Checklist (Bab 15) ``` PAPER STRUCTURE CHECKLIST Title : ____________________ Target : [ ] Jurnal [ ] Konferensi [ ] Laporan Section Check: [ ] Abstract — masalah, metode, hasil utama, kontribusi (max 250 kata) [ ] Introduction — konteks → gap → RQ → kontribusi → struktur paper [ ] Related Work — concept-centric, gap positioning [ ] Method — reproducible: desain, variabel, metrik, setup, prosedur [ ] Results — tabel + grafik + observasi (tanpa interpretasi) [ ] Discussion — interpretasi, perbandingan, implikasi, limitation [ ] Conclusion — jawaban RQ, kontribusi, future work Consistency Matrix: [ ] RQ di Introduction = RQ di Method = RQ di Conclusion [ ] Variabel di Method = variabel di Results [ ] Klaim di Discussion didukung data di Results [ ] Limitasi di Discussion diaddress di Conclusion/Future Work Writing Quality: [ ] Clarity — mudah dipahami tanpa re-read [ ] Precision — tidak ada istilah ambigu [ ] Conciseness — tidak ada kalimat redundan ``` --- ## A.16 — Defense Preparation Sheet (Bab 16) ``` DEFENSE PREPARATION Slide Deck Plan: Total slides : ____ (target: 10–12 konten + title/closing) Time per slide: ~2 min Total time : ____ menit Slide Outline: | # | Pesan Utama | Visual | Waktu | |---|-------------|--------|-------| | 1 | Title | | 30s | | 2 | Problem & Motivation | | 2min | | 3 | Research Gap | | 2min | | ...| ... | | | Anticipatory Defense Matrix: | Kategori | Pertanyaan Potensial | Jawaban (data-based) | |----------|---------------------|---------------------| | Problem | | | | Gap | | | | Method | | | | Results | | | | Generalization | | | Latihan: Latihan 1: [tanggal] — [catatan timing & feedback] Latihan 2: [tanggal] — [catatan timing & feedback] Latihan 3: [tanggal] — [catatan timing & feedback] ``` ---